National Disasters
It’s September 11th, of course. Four years since the terrorist attacks on New York and Washington.
We live about 30-35 miles from New York city. At lunchtime on that day, Mom and I walked up the street and over the hill, and took this picture–that huge plume of smoke on the horizon? The one that, by dinner stretched far, far to the right, well out of the bounds of this photo? The one that’s bigger than any of the clouds in the sky? That’s where the World Trade Center used to stand. When the light was right in the morning, or when they were lit at night, we could see the towers clearly. All the smaller buildings were–and are–mere smudges on the horizon, but the WTC stood tall.
I bring this up today for two reasons. One, because I don’t think we as a country can afford to forget that attack. It’s so easy to get caught up with the political quagmire of the war in Iraq, and forget that we at least started all of this for a reason. A good reason. Should we have invaded Afghanistan to get rid of the Taliban who helped formulate that attack? Yes, I think that was entirely the right thing to do. Should we have invaded Iraq? No, I don’t think so. But the point is that we were attacked and it was horrible; it was huge; and we can never, ever forget that. Nor can we forget that our proudest moments that September came when we as a country pulled together. For a few weeks, a few months, political parties didn’t matter. Instead, we did what we had to do to help the people, the cities, the country.
But the second reason–we’re obviously facing another huge catastrophe down in Louisiana and Mississippi. This one, there’s no one to blame for the disaster itself, of course, but the blame game following this crisis nevertheless is going on and on and on. City government wasn’t talking to State government which wasn’t talking to Federal government, which wasn’t talking to anyone. Red Cross wasn’t talking to FEMA which wasn’t talking to the Coast Guard. Human rescuers weren’t talking to Pet rescuers. No coordination of effort, which means some things were duplicated, and some actions never happened at all. But everyone was talking to the Press to tell about how hard they were working. It’s getting better now, of course, but really, it’s been almost two weeks–could it really have gotten worse? I’m appalled at what I’ve heard about FEMA (and that debit card idea that they decided they couldn’t handle because they didn’t have enough people? Don’t get me started.)
However, I am proud of the way the American people have handled this. Personal donations to charities like the Red Cross have broken all records. People have opened their houses to those who lost their homes. Schools all around the country have opened arms to displaced students. Food, water, clothing, diapers, afghans, backpacks of school supplies . . . all of these and lots more have been donated to help. Volunteers are wading through that muck in New Orleans, looking for lost pets. And the stories out of Baton Rouge and Houston? Wow. Those cities (and many others) are going above and beyond to squeeze in thousands upon thousands of suddenly homeless people.
There is no question that all sorts of things were not done, or were done incorrectly during this crisis. We need to fix that; we cannot afford to ever let this happen again. I mean, sure, geographically this hurricane was huge–I heard that the devastated area is the size of Great Britain. How DO you fix that all at once? You just can’t. There are going to be logistical nightmares and failures, because on a scale like that, it’s simply not possible to do everything right. But it seems like we really should have managed to do more, on a governmental level. What’s the point of having a department for Federal emergencies that can’t handle emergencies? We have to fix that.
What really grieves me, though, is that–on just about every official level–this seems to be tearing us apart. Everyone seems to be so involved in spreading the blame, pointing fingers, that even though so many individuals are giving time and money and homespace to help, there are more who are taking this opportunity to say, “It’s all their fault,” and pointing fingers, instead of asking, “How do we fix it?”
And now, on the anniversary of the greatest attack on our country in recent memory, and barely two weeks after the worst natural disaster of our country, it seems to me that we need to learn from both of these disasters. As individuals, we obviously know how to pitch in and help one another. This is twice in four years that we’ve proved that. However, we also clearly need to have a direction to point our anger when these things happen (heaven forbid), because otherwise, that rage blows up in our face. As if the disaster itself wasn’t horrific enough. As if we can afford to splinter off into bitter groups so busy placing blame that we never do anything to make sure it doesn’t happen again. We need a strong leader to help us focus–we had that on 9/11/01–both Rudy Giuliani and (yes) Pres. Bush did a great job of getting people to work together. For Katrina, though, nobody filled that role, and in that void, we instead have a whirlpool of hatred and anger.
And–let’s not forget this–we have good neighbors. Yes, a lot of people in the world wondered why we, the richest country on the planet, could possibly need help–but for the most part, when we really needed help, it was offered, willingly, generously, from other countries, even many of the ones that hate us.
What does all this mean? You’ve got me. It just seems to me that one disaster we handled wonderfully, and one we handled disastrously. They were completely different kinds of disasters, of course, with different requirements and different difficulties. But since the one comes so close to the anniversary of the other, there are parallels that you can’t help but make.
Even though it’s too late to save the people who died in either one–I could wish that we would allow our common grief in Katrina’s wake to pull us together, rather than to plow deeper chasms between us. I think if there’s any one lesson, it’s that in both catastrophes, we saw the best of humanity–its caring, its generosity, its willingness to help, to share. I don’t think the people who offered their spare rooms, or who are donating hours of their time at the local Red Cross bothered to stop and ask “Are they Democrats?” “Are they Republicans?” “Are they White?” before they jumped in to help. Why should the rest of us? What’s the point of pointing fingers? We are all humans. We all failed the people of the Gulf coast in this disaster–because, let’s not forget, “we ARE the people” of the government, no matter who we voted for. And yet, we also all selflessly helped–regardless of personal politics, race, or class. Isn’t that all that really matters?















Tannenbaum.
House Calls


