And The Winner Is….

20051206_1230 I want to thank all of you who voted for your favorite button. There’s really no question that the Everest and Streamline buttons matched best, but I wasn’t really looking for a button to “match” so much as “pop.”

And I never promised this was a democracy, either, so . . . I went with my first choice. There’s just something about the way this Seabird button gleams and shine, and I like the way its coppery color goes with the underlying brownish tone to the red. You’ll just have to trust me that, in person, it’s a great choice.

What’s that? You’re seeing a sewn on button and you’re assuming that the sweater is finished?

Really?

Whatever would give you that idea?

20051206_1242 Well, maybe it’s because I DID!

Union Square Market Pullover, from the Interweave Knits Fall 2005 issue. Designed by Kate Gilbert (a brand new Mom, too, just last week).

Knitted in Rowan’s 4-ply Cashsoft, in “Redwood,” with trim in “Rose Lake.”

I modified the sleeves, making the cuffs narrower–as much as I liked the “bell” of the originals, they would have gotten in my way all the time. I also–as you heard over and over–had to recalculate basically everything about this sweater. My stitch gauge was about 2/3 of what the pattern called for (and this, using the same weight yarn AND smaller needles), and my row gauge was about 3/4 that of the pattern. Every single number had to be recalculated. All the shaping (done by short rows) had to be reconfigured. I’ve never worked so hard on somebody else’s pattern before! Not because the pattern wasn’t well put together–I thought it really was–just because nothing I was working with matched up (grin).

On the plus side, I apparently did the math correctly, because it seems to fit really well. What a relief! Sorry about the lousy picture, though.

As to the buttons? I really do like the coppery Seabird button, but I do have to admit . . . I’d love something even more special. Just because. Nancy made an excellent point, that I had to practically climb a mountain to get this done. I’ll keep my eyes out . . . I can always sew on different buttons if I want to, right??

Speaking of which, I’ve now got three good links for button places. Button Drawer. Button Shoppe. And JHB Intl.

Not only that, in thanks for all the button votes, I’ll pass on my favorite method for quick and easy sewings-on of buttons:

  • Start with a double-long length of thread.
  • Fold it in half, and thread the crease of the fold through your needle–keeping the two ends together. You will now have two thicknesses of thread in the needle.
  • Insert into the material where you want to sew your button. Pull through, but not all the way through.
  • Thread the button onto the needle (either going through its shank, or up one hole, down the next, depending on your type of button.)
  • Insert the needle back down through the material, catching the loop from the original fold underneath. Pull tight to secure the thread.
  • Go back up and down two more times to secure the button. (If using 4-holed buttons, make that three trips for each set of holes.)
  • Before going back down to the wrong side of your fabric the last time, wrap your thread around the shank of the button (or around the threads securing the button). This gives added strength, and also lifts the button ever so slightly up from the fabric, making it easier to work with.
  • Insert the needle through to the wrong side, and prepare to tie your finishing knot. With your needle, catch one or two of the lines of thread you just laid down as you sewed the button, and pull the needle through, leaving a loop at the end. Insert the needle through that loop, pull to secure. (Repeat with another knot, if desired.)
  • And that’s it! The double-thickness of thread means you have to make fewer “passes” through the button to really secure it. The fold at the beginning means you don’t have to start with a knot at all. Quickest, easiest way of securely sewing a button I’ve ever tried.

20 Responses to “And The Winner Is….”

  1. I love it! I think it looks fantastic, fits perfectly, and the button! whoo! :)
    [now I want to make one, but I am staying away from 4ply garments for now… ;) ]

  2. Great job, I love it!

  3. Look at you, all cute in your new sweater. ;) I love it. That wouldn’t have been my first choice for a button (I was going for matchy-matchy) but it works perfectly. Very nice.

  4. Very Nice! I like the modifications to the cuffs you made, still in the spirit of the pattern but more practical. The button is cool!

  5. The sweater looks great, Deb! Congratulations on a job well done.

  6. Your sweater looks wonderful on you! Thank you for the button tutorial. Its basic, but no one really talks about how to do it. THanks

  7. Gorgeous! It makes me want to knit one! Too many upcoming holiday knitting projects, however. Maybe I’ll treat myself to a January Union Sq Market Pullover!

    Cheers!

  8. thank you for that button info! i knew about the “shank” part, and my grandmother taught me the same finishing knot, but i like the beginning oodles! i’ll ahve to keep that in mind.

    and it does look great!

  9. Wow! Wow! Wow! Great job. And I agree, the button is unique and give is pizazz. I looks great on you. Congratulations!

  10. You did it and beautifully. I bet it feels gorgeous in cashsoft too. Somehow I knew that you were going to make that choice with your buttons, you have to go with what looks great when it’s right in front of you. A photo (well in my case anyway!) never looks quite the same for comparisons.

  11. Fab! Looks like it fits like a glove, too. Great job, Deb. Even though the final button wasn’t my first (or *ahem* even my 2nd) choice, it looks fantastic! It’s a good thing it wasn’t up to us to decide which one you used.

  12. Beautiful! Just lovely! Congrats on a job well done!

  13. Beautiful! I do like that button choice, it does indeed pop. The sweater looks great on you.

  14. it’s sooooo pretty and looks great on you!

  15. It’s fabulous! Great job with “the maths”, I love it when everything works out. And the cashsoft is so yummy.

  16. Beautiful job! Your sweater-fu is strong!

  17. It looks great - whatchu talkin’ about ‘lousy picture’?!? oh, stop!

  18. It looks fantastic…just beautiful. all those calculations were well worth it in the end.

  19. I thought about Chappy when I heard a story on NPR about the Pet Cell phone. It’s even bone shaped. Hmmm….
    http://www.engadget.com/entry/7042716626214795/

  20. Beautiful sweater. You look great.

Discussion Area - Leave a Comment